decide game:

quantum technologies

Group 3 – Participant 4

Story cards

Read all the cards from this category, choose the one that looks more interesting to you and explain it to the rest of the group.

david díaz

Story Card 1

I am a historian and a university lecturer.

I think many people put a lot of pressure on scientists to quickly turn their research into applications that benefit society. I think we should not demand results so soon. We should be patient and continue to foster research.

For example, while the theoretical principles on which lasers are based were known back in 1917, it was not until the 1960s that we had the first prototype. It took many more years for it to become an essential technological tool.

alina anderson

Story Card 13

I am finishing my secondary school studies and have to decide what to do in the future. I have liked science since I was young, but I do not know which subject to study in college.

I have recently been finding out about progress in the world of quantum physics. It all sounds very promising. I am excited about the idea of being able to be involved in the expansion of scientific knowledge!

In a sense, people who work in science are the explorers of modern times.

ernesto espinosa

Story Card 15

We could not understand modern medicine without quantum physics. At the hospital where I work as a doctor, we often use MRI scans to detect tumours and other types of pathologies. Quantum physics is key to understanding this technology's basic processes. In addition, lasers (another quantum technology) have become essential tools for extreme-precision surgery. These are just two examples of how quantum physics can help medicine!

info cards

 

Read all cards from this category, choose the two that look more interesting and explain them to the rest of the group.

 

Randomness

Info Card 5

The results of a measurement are probabilistic: we have no way of knowing what will happen when we measure a single particle, but we can accurately calculate the probability of each possible result.

Applications: random numbers. In fact, this is the only way to obtain completely random numbers. Random numbers have applications in cryptography, simulations, gambling, etc.

Quside, an ICFO spin-off, has invented a random number generator based on quantum physics.

uncertainty principle

Info Card 7

It is not possible to measure incompatible observables, such as the position and speed of a particle, at the same time and with arbitrary precision.

This is also known as Heisenberg's uncertainty principle.

The more precise the value of one observable, the more uncertain the other will be. For example, if I know the position of one particle with high precision, then the measurement of its velocity will be highly uncertain (i.e. it will have a large error).

Applications: sensors. We can use this property to obtain ultra-sensitive measurements from magnetic fields or gravity.

tunnel effect

Info Card 11

Imagine a ball in a bowl. It can escape the bowl only if we push it with sufficient energy; otherwise, it will get to a certain height and fall back.

At quantum scale, particles can overcome certain barriers even if they do not have enough energy. It is as if a tunnel allowed them to cross the barrier without expending energy (tunnel effect).

Applications: electron microscopy (a very thin metal point is placed near a surface and "rips" electrons through the tunnel effect.)

interferometry

Info Card 22

Interferometers are devices that use interference as a tool for very precise measurements.

Quantum properties allow us to further increase accuracy and measure things that are too small for classical physics.

Applications: gravitational waves, super-resolution microscopy, photolithography (printing materials with light), variations in the ground gravitational field (useful for knowing the levels of oil deposits or aquifers).

thinking cards

 

Read all the cards from this category, choose the one that looks more interesting to you and explain it to the rest of the group.

 

cryptography

Thinking Card 3

In principle, quantum physics provides theoretical protocols that are invulnerable to cyber attacks. Nevertheless, some scientists have managed to break the security of existing quantum protocols because of weaknesses in their implementation. Given the finite precision of any human construction, can we rely on theoretical predictions about applications?

 

fake news

Thinking Card 10

It is important for people to be informed about scientific advances so they can express critical opinions about news in the media, advertising, social networks, etc. and avoid falling for scams or misunderstandings. However, sometimes information comes from pseudoscientific sources of dubious reliability.

How should we manage this often dubious information flow?

 

DECISIon

 

The time and resources available to solve the major problems affecting society are limited. Imagine being part of the committee that has to decide how to invest money to develop quantum technologies at European level over the next few years: since you know that that quantum technologies could benefit society in many different ways, how many resources would you commit to developing them?

This is not an individual decision: each group must reach a unanimous conclusion by arguing properly and rationally based on the facts you have learned so far. There is no right or wrong answer. Like many things in life, it depends on your point of view, your priorities, etc.

 

quantum technologies are the future

Option 1

Their applications in all fields of human activity will radically change our lives, just as electricity and electronics once did. We must invest as much as we can in their development, to make them commercially viable as soon as possible. 

 

quantum technologies are still too far away

Opció 2

We should not be fooled by illusory promises. We have gone very far with traditional technologies and we still have a long way to go: we should keep the current investment in quantum technologies at the same level. Let scientists do their work and continue to research, focusing on maintaining and improving the technologies that we already have. 

 

we should prioritise

Option 3

Research into quantum physics and its applications is positive, but we currently have other far more important and pressing issues, such as hunger, poverty, wars and terrorism. Let us maintain research, but invest our money to find solutions to the major problems our society has today.  

we should boost basic science

Option 4

Quantum technologies are very promising, but if they are to be effective, they require solid knowledge of their foundations. We should invest in fundamental research: a better understanding of the foundations of quantum physics will naturally lead to the development of its applications.

Icons made by Freepik and Eucalyp from Flaticon
Share This